When customers talk to us about switching to alternative fuels, one question pops up frequently: Is renewable diesel the same as biodiesel? The short answer is no. While both come from renewable feedstocks, their different chemical makeup means one may suit your business better.
Read on to learn how these two sustainable fuels are made, how they differ chemically, and what difference they can make for your operations.
How Renewable Diesel and Biodiesel Are Made
Both renewable diesel and biodiesel usually start with the same feedstocks, including vegetable oils, soybean oil, used cooking grease, or animal fats. However, the processes that convert those ingredients into diesel differ significantly between these two fuels.
Biodiesel production uses transesterification, where oils or fats react with methanol and a catalyst. This converts the feedstock’s triglycerides into fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) and glycerin. The industry then reclaims and distributes glycerin for pharmaceutical and cosmetic uses, while using the esters as biodiesel.
In contrast, hydrotreating is typically used to produce renewable diesel fuel. In this production process, oils and fats react with hydrogen under high temperatures and pressures in the presence of a catalyst, removing oxygen and converting the feedstock into a paraffinic hydrocarbon fuel.
The Chemical Structure of Biodiesel vs. Renewable Diesel
We won’t get too scientific, but to understand how biodiesel and renewable diesel perform differently, we need to compare their chemical structures with regular petroleum diesel.
Although petroleum diesel comes from crude oil and renewable diesel production relies on renewable feedstocks, the hydrotreating process we explained above converts those feedstocks into hydrocarbons. As a result, renewable diesel is chemically identical to petroleum diesel.
At the other end of the spectrum, biodiesel differs fundamentally from petroleum diesel since biodiesel’s FAME molecules contain oxygen in addition to hydrogen and carbon. This difference affects performance, stability, and compatibility with certain engine components, which we’ll expand on in a moment.
The Practical Difference Between Biodiesel and Renewable Diesel
Both fuels can reduce reliance on fossil fuels and lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions compared to petroleum diesel. However, the right choice for your business depends on how it performs in your storage tanks, equipment, and operating conditions. When trying to decide between the two, here’s what you should consider:
Blend Limits
Because renewable diesel is chemically equivalent to petroleum diesel and meets ASTM D975 specifications, you can use it in equipment designed for conventional diesel without blending.
Biodiesel, however, is usually blended with conventional diesel due to its lower energy density and tendency to gel in cold weather at higher concentrations. It’s commonly sold in blends such as B5 (5% biodiesel) and B20 (20% biodiesel). If you choose to run biodiesel, here’s what you should know:
- B5 adheres to ASTM D975 standards, doesn’t require any special pump labeling, and is safe for any compression-ignition engine, according to the United States Department of Energy.
- B6–B20 has to meet ASTM D7467 specifications and is generally safe for use in unmodified engines. These blends typically balance cost, cold-weather performance, and engine compatibility well.
- Running blends higher than B20 may impact fuel economy and require specialized storage, handling, and equipment modifications.
Cold-Weather Performance
Arguably, the most important measure of a fuel’s cold-weather reliability is its cloud point — the temperature at which crystals that can clog fuel filters and interfere with engine operation begin to form.
In a 2024 study funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, researchers at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory measured the cloud point of a soy-based, pure biodiesel sample at -0.6°C (31°F), and a renewable diesel sample at -19.6°C (-3°F). That’s a difference of approximately 34°F, giving renewable diesel a substantial cold-weather advantage in this comparison.
However, the study above analyzed 100% biodiesel, which is rarely used before blending with petroleum diesel. B5 diesel blends typically have a cloud point similar to No. 2 diesel, while B20 blends usually only raise the cloud point by 2°–7°F. So, while renewable diesel may have the edge, proper seasonal blending and adequate fuel winterization can make biodiesel suitable for winter use.
Storage Stability
Biodiesels are more susceptible to oxidation than their conventional counterparts. Without proper inventory rotation and tank maintenance, exposure to oxygen, heat, and contaminants can create acids, gums, and sediments that compromise fuel quality and clog filters.
In contrast, renewable diesel is closer in oxidation stability to petroleum diesel, making it better suited to long-term storage. That said, good tank maintenance still matters, since water and contamination can compromise either fuel.
Engine Compatibility and Warranties
Renewable diesel is designed to meet the same specifications as conventional diesel, making it a drop-in fuel that’s suitable for existing diesel engines without modification.
Biodiesel compatibility depends on the blend you’re using and your engine’s manufacturer. B5 is broadly approved, while B20’s approval can vary by engine model and year. Higher blends often require modifications before use.
Neither fuel automatically voids an engine warranty. However, using an unapproved blend or one that doesn’t meet the relevant renewable fuel standard can create problems that may not be covered. Always review your equipment manufacturer’s recommendations before switching fuel types.
Deciding Which Fuel Is Right for Your Business? Venture Fuels Can Help
The right diesel depends on your equipment, storage capacity, typical operating temperatures, and use case. As a wholesale supplier serving businesses across the Midwest, Venture Fuels can help you review those details and determine which option makes sense for your equipment and operation. Contact our team today to talk through your fuel options.